Andrew Schmucker faced legal troubles after his time on “Return to Amish.” He was arrested on charges related to drug possession and driving under the influence.
Andrew Schmucker, who appeared on the reality TV show “Return to Amish,” experienced a difficult period following his stint on television. After the show, which documented the lives of individuals leaving their Amish communities to explore the outside world, Andrew found himself on the wrong side of the law. He was arrested on multiple occasions, with charges ranging from drug possession to driving under the influence (DUI).
His legal issues began to surface publicly in 2014 when he was taken into custody for heroin possession. This was a significant fall for Andrew, who had been trying to adapt to a new lifestyle away from his strict Amish upbringing. The show had provided a platform for him to share his journey, but unfortunately, his struggles with the law overshadowed his attempts to integrate into mainstream society.
Andrew’s arrests and subsequent legal battles were a stark reminder of the challenges that individuals can face when transitioning from a sheltered community to the broader, more complex outside world. His story also highlighted the potential pitfalls of reality TV fame, as the pressure and exposure can sometimes lead to negative outcomes for participants. Despite these setbacks, fans of the show have expressed hope that Andrew would find his way and overcome the obstacles that he encountered after “Return to Amish.”